Retro Review: Y2K Sportster Custom Was the Best Sporty Ever
An unbeatable combination of performance fused with classic styling.
Classic Performance
The 2000 XL 1200C was a crowd favorite when the middle-aged Sportster lineup entered the new millennium. Introduced in 1996, the Custom model had Big Twin features stuffed into the compact XL frame. The 2000 Custom benefited from engine improvements and brake updates, making it an unbeatable combination of performance fused with classic styling.
Slim-Lined Looks
In typical Harley-Davidson format, the Custom's styling remained constant from its introduction up until 2003. The following year, the XL 1200C received a new frame and rubber-mounted engine, along with a reshaped 4.5-gallon gas tank. The updated design lasted until 2010 when the Custom lost its slim-lined looks and inherited a more beefy appearance for 2011.
Go-To Platform
The Custom was at the apex of its design for solid-mount Sportsters. Introduced in 1986, the Evolution engine replaced the Ironhead, which had powered the first XL-series starting in 1957. Harley-Davidson advertising of the day called the 2000 Sportster “The essential beauty of bare bones.” The MoCo was spot-on. Due to their simplicity, solid-mount Sportsters have since become the go-to platform for customizers.
Crank Flex
Many of the Custom's updates were inside the engine. From 2000 until 2003, all Sportsters were mechanically the same. They were fitted with redesigned crankcases with machined lifter housings and steel-bodied lifters. The cases also made room for a redesigned three-piece crank that allowed for some flex. It was a design first conceived for the Buell Single, aimed at improving performance while cutting costs.
Smooth Accelerator
The straight-pin crank was more than just a cost-effective move. The result of a lightened flywheel translated into quicker engine response. In stock form, the 2000 XL 1200C accelerated quickly, pulling smoothly well past 5000 rpm, but with a touch less torque than the XL1200S Sport. Shifting and finding neutral also improved, with less crank mass to work against synchronizing the five-speed transmission.
Lavish Touring
Available in 883cc and 1200cc engine displacements, the Custom was instantly recognizable due to its 21-inch spoked front wheel and solid 16-inch rear wheel. Custom's also received a lavish coating of chrome on almost all exposed parts and engine cases. With a destination in mind, Motor Company brochures pictured the Custom outfitted for touring, with auxiliary lights, saddlebags and both rider and pillion backrests.
Droopy Improvement
Unique to the Custom was a reverse-mounted speedometer and a hefty set of risers. While it cured the lollipop effect on other Sportster models, the drop-down gauge was sometimes called 'droopy.' One improvement that was not lacking was the brakes. Harley-Davidson engineers took a simple and effective approach with fixed two-piston calipers and discs that allowed for thermal expansion without distortion.
Y2K Hype
As of 2020, the Custom is no longer included in the Motor Company's domestic XL lineup. The bucolic promotional depictions of the 2000 XL 1200C were in stark contrast to the imminent fear of mass turn-of-the-millennium technological failure. The Custom stood apart from the hyped Y2K doom as an elegant reminder that simple ingenuity is the best.
For help with your do-it-yourself maintenance and repair projects, please visit our how-to section in the forum.
