Something I noticed on my '07 that is differentfrom my old FXRS: When in 1st gear on my 5-speed, if I step down on the shifter it goes down an inch or so and springs back up. On my 6-speed, if I'm in 1st gear and step onthe shifter, itwon't move. It's as hard and immobile as stepping on a brick. Evidently some internal difference in the shifting mechanism between the old and new.

 

Exactly what mine does. My buddy the indy said it is probably the gears not meshing. He thinks even though I don't get the Harley clunk it's going into gear once I release the clutch and start moving. While still not moving if I shift back to neutral when I get this and then let out on clutch a bit it will clunk into first gear.