There's a lot of folks who won't use anything but a $500 jack, but the Harbor Freight jack is all I've ever used and it works fine for me. No issues ever. There's about a million threads on this subject. Btw, the word "lift" usually denotes a lift table, not a jack.
Like you, I went to our local HF store to look over and test both of their m/c jacks for quality, stability and functionality. Not going to tell anyone how to spend their well-earned money, especially these days, but my bike sits on a J&S jack. Wasn't impressed with HF at all...JMO and you could see things different. Not trying to start another "jack war" here, just voicing my input.
I did a survey on here looking at mishaps. There were no reported incidences of jack failure but numerous examples of operator error. Virtually all mishaps flowed from faulty tie-down practices.
I use one it works fine...do a search on here and you will find hundreds of threads about this lift and others that will help you in making an informed decision.