Pull out that Hayden Tensioner and check the two springs. I just did the same thing and found the larger spring broken. I just reinstalled the HD oem tensioner back on my bike the noise is gone.
Last edited by knife_edge; 08-12-2013 at 10:54 PM.
Eric, I was looking at the pics more, is that an SE comp?? Looks like a stock one for the 09.
Stock not the SE, though I've read that there were problems with those too. I replaced mine with another stock unit after reading about similar problems with the SE. Guess I'll find out with my 11 Limited I think that comes stock with the SE compensator.