I recently installed a 2008 rear fender to my 1990 bike. It is not a direct swap, as the later one is shorter, I suspect to create enough space to get the battery under the seat. I bought mine with all the rear lamps, which look similar but are fitted differently, which adds a query if you are looking at a bare fender. The 08 is exactly the same width as my 90, so bound to be the same for your 95. Hope that helps a bit!
I also want to change the rear fender on my 2001 RK to get rid of the big light bar. Maybe a CVO fender and tail lights. Not sure if this will fit. I'm not worried about a little modifing to get to work just not sure if should spend the money