I ordered a bunch of stuff from New Castle but learned a lesson. Don't order extra stuff if your not sure you're going to keep it. I ordered a couple of different gear shift linkages because I wasn't sure which one I would like better on my bike. When I went to return it and some other items I didn't need I got charge a re-stocking fee because some of the parts I ordered were not normally stocked and had to be ordered. A $60 mistake. I won't order from them again unless they have the best price and I know I won't be returning it if I don't like it.

 

I have ordered from LS and New Castle, both are great. However, New Castle ships items lightning fast.

 

I've had great luck with these guys. Usually items have to be ordered in to them from the MoCo, but everything ships pretty quickly even with the "special order" deal. My Tallboy handlebars for the Street Glide should be here by Friday, 17AUG12 (ordered Friday 10AUG12 at 21:55; they expect to ship by Wednesday 15AUG12). That Tour Pak and AirWing Rack on my bike came from them!

Jon from Horny Toad HD has also been mentioned...he's got excellent pricing as well, but I'd bet if you're going over the $100 mark, Kutter (Cyclepartsforless.com) will be a bit cheaper. Kutter also lists a ton of other parts such as Kuryakyn and most Drag Specialties stuff, and adding them to an order (even if it's a few bucks to get you over $100) counts toward the free shipping level.