Not local MC....at least probably not......visiting in Ontario from Wisconsin, someone in the neighborhood knows something. Don't think it's a pro job.
File a stolen report in Ontario where it was stolen and also one in Wisconsin where you live. That will insure it gets entered as stolen in both countries. Ontario enters things into their own database and its separate from the database that is used in the US. Also I'm not sure if Ontario enters the plate and VIN number or just one of them.
Man that sucks. My apologies that it happened in my back yard. Bastards must have had an eye on the bike.
I have a feeling she's going to come back to you!!!!