Talk me outta Rinehart TD's...
#32
#34
#36
[quote=Leftcoaster;9348412]That's not a secret, a lot of people know about this, but hurt performance may be a little misunderstood. True duals do not reap the benefit of scavenging therefore they give up some low end torque, which is more desireable to get a heavy touring machine moving. The trade off is they carry HP a little further out. Basically true duals shift the TQ/HP to the right a little bit. Not necessarily bad just different performance, people like duals for the sound not performance, anyone performance oriented will tell you 2:1 is the way to go. You can't have everything, where would you put it all?
#37
Yes, they do reduce performance compared to a system with a crossover because reversion forces are not controlled as well, which as Fabrik8r said is manifested mostly in the low-end of the performance equation. Fuel Moto sells all types of systems including TD's and have done hundreds of dyno-tunes for many years on all kinds of configurations, and if anyone wants first-hand info on this I would recommend contacting them or any other experienced dyno-tuner for more info.
Last edited by iclick; 02-04-2012 at 06:52 PM.
#38
TD's don't perform as well as a non-cat 2-1-2, 2-1, or the older stock systems ('08 and earlier), all other factors being equal. IOW, both with the same AC and muffler upgrades and a good tune. Whether any given rider can feel the difference is another matter, and I think most buy these systems because of their unique stereo sound and cosmetic appeal. If there weren't gains to be made from using a crossover pipe HD would not have spent the extra money engineering these into stock bikes for decades.
#39
You're not an idiot at all, of course. Like cams or most anything else, exhaust systems are full of compromises, and cosmetic appearance is most important to you. The next guy might prefer a better performance bump with another exhaust configuration, but neither decision is wrong if the rider's priorities and needs have been satisfied.
#40
Yes, they do reduce performance compared to a system with a crossover because reversion forces are not controlled as well, which as Fabrik8r said is manifested mostly in the low-end of the performance equation. Fuel Moto sells all types of systems including TD's and have done hundreds of dyno-tunes for many years on all kinds of configurations, and if anyone wants first-hand info on this I would recommend contacting them or any other experienced dyno-tuner for more info.
I guess we're gonna have to agree to disagree 'cause there's no way any stock 'Y' pipe system can make more power than a TD with stepped headers. You're offering your personal opinion and claim it as fact and it just isn't true.
I'm also a big fan of Fuel Moto and they do indeed 'know their stuff'. And it's quite true that a 2-1 will produce more power than a TD. And it's also true that the Rinehart TD moves the power a little to the right, but the difference at say 1500-2000 rpm is minimal on a stock motor and nearly imperceptible.
Your claim that a stepped header TD 'reduces power' is pure bunk and not supported by any data I'm aware of.