I would be more concernd about someone pouring some crap in my tank than stealing my fuel
I will keep the stock key, gives me a piece of mind.

 

Changed to the push button a few weeks ago, good improvement over the keyed door.

 

I have the locking one and am ready to replace it with the other. The button is about 3/16" wide and flush with the locking mechanism. It is almost to push in with a finger and I have to use a key to push it down. I am going to replace it with the non-locking one very soon!

 

I like mine; it was on my 2010 and now my 2011. No problems, shuts good, opens quick and easy.

+1

 

Yeah mine too. I just spent about half an hour tweaking the latch and the spring. Now it works great. I can open it with just a push of my thumb.

 

A little adjustment goes a long way.

 

I have the push button best 25 bucks i ever spent on my bike.

 

Mine rattles too,I even went as far as stuffing little pieces of sponge under the button,to lessen the vibration .But I haven't noticed the rattle since I installed the 4" Rineharts.

 

A time saver don't have to hunt for my keys. Looks good too.

 

I installed mine as one of the first mods. Read about here and love it so far. No problems after 5K miles.