Did some looking around, and was able to try on a few of the helmets we were looking at (IS-33, CL-33, EXO-200, RJ Air Plat R, etc). We both liked the IS-33. Neither of us were thrilled at the futuristic look of the outside, but it did seem comfortable to wear. We'll keep an eye out for a good price on the IS-33.
Thanks everybody for your input.
If you like the IS-33 and want a more tame look check out the FS-3. My wife and I both have one and love them. You can find them for around 85-90 dollars online.
We ended up going with the IS-33. We found two online in our sizes over the winter for $68 or something like that each, new and shipped from a dealer going out of business. We are quite happy with them, when I get some time, I'll post a thorough review of them here.