The colors in the badge work very well with your bike. The white, especially, draws my eye to the wide white walls. My vote it to keep it.
Thanks and I'm glad you see that too. That's exactly what I want; to tie the tank in with the whitewalls. I was also considering the red '40's badges but thought the '63 style would look better with my bike's color scheme.
i did the same thing with my 09 except i chose the arrow style from '59 i think. the red ones. then i got touch up paint and painted over the red with my bike colors. did it all in photoshop first of course just like you and tried every color combination i could think of.
yours look great on that black bike!
I guess I'm alone but I love the stock "coin" emblem on the RKC; it's huge and makes the 6 gal. tank look smaller.
I've had some background in design and sometimes people often confuse their distaste of what's familiar with genuine appeal. Either way, just go with what works for you.