The cig lighter won't work unless you smoke!!!!

 

sgdiesel's comment on it being the F&A fuse is correct for 09 Street Glides also. I just changed my fuse today with one of the "smart" fuses that is supposed to glow when it blows so my feeble mind hopefully does not have to remember next time.

 

The issue is more likely that the socket in the fairing is specific for a lighter (at least it is on my 09 Ultra). You can pull the front fairing off and replace the socket with the HD accessory socket; it is a direct replacemt, it comes with a nice rubber style cap too that's nice when you're not using it. Also, the cord that come with it can be used for something else in the future since it has the correct accessory plug ( you won't need that, just use the wires that connect the current lighter)

 

That was #4 on my winter to do list.
I've had two lighters ripped off over the years....both at Sturgis....both at the Full Throttle Saloon.