Farmers insurance here in Wyoming, mid-high levels of coverage with $500 deductible is $183 a year.

 

Went through HD Insurance and got a SafeCo policy for $500/yr, $250 deductible, incl. $3500 bling insurance. Was cheaper than Geico & Progressive for me. Try Geico, Progressive, and HD Financial. One of those will probably be about as cheap as you could find anywhere.

 

Make sure you are looking at apples to apples and oranges to oranges. Many people carry larger amount of liability while others carry the state minimums. This along with full coverage,where you live, and deductables make quite of bit of differnence in the policy amount.

 

We had both of our bikes thru Progressive and with full coverage on both it was around $850 a year with 3k worth of bling insurance. Oue dealer was telling us about Rider Insurance, so we called them just to check. They only cover motorcycles and were over $100 cheaper than Progressive and come with 8k worth of bling insurance. Plus your insurance is stacked with them and you get a 10% discount on each bike for having a multiple bike policy.

 

$296 with a $250 detuct. on my 2007 ElectraGlide through Foremost in Michigan. I live in Wisconsin and have shopped coverage and Foremost was the best bang for the buck!