That 200mm rear tire/fender is from 2007 and up. Any 07 and up fender will work if you are looking to replace. Just add paint.
I found one cheap on craigs (maybe) and was thinking of using it as a base to fit my Super Glide which has a 200 stuffed under the stock fender, it would need to be narrowed since the stock fender is only 8.25" wide - might be able to add a little more than that but its already wider than the Wide Glide fenders (which are 9") that don't fit.........not sure if its something I will do or not just yet as it would also need an extension added to the front and all the holes welded and redrilled.