Heritage Classic vs fatboy
#21
So I was at the dealership looking at bikes while waiting for my own. You know dreaming of one for the future.
Just curious with what you guys went with and why. I like the looks of the Fatboy more. Not to say the heritage looks bad by any means. But the woman told me it's an old man's bike. However the better deal seems to be on the Heritage Classic. You get windshield, sissy bar and pad and saddle bags, pretty nice looking ones for like 1000 more.
The fatboy seat seemed more comfy, but maybe after riding awhile it wouldn't be. I like the fatboy more but the heritage is growing on me, so what do you guys like more and why?
Just curious with what you guys went with and why. I like the looks of the Fatboy more. Not to say the heritage looks bad by any means. But the woman told me it's an old man's bike. However the better deal seems to be on the Heritage Classic. You get windshield, sissy bar and pad and saddle bags, pretty nice looking ones for like 1000 more.
The fatboy seat seemed more comfy, but maybe after riding awhile it wouldn't be. I like the fatboy more but the heritage is growing on me, so what do you guys like more and why?
#23
Same family but they are really two very different bikes. You need to sit on both and hopefully test ride each. I thought the FB looked great but I really didn't like the way it "fit" me. I have short legs and short arms so I am sure that was an issue there.
The Heritage was a perfect fit for me.
The Heritage was a perfect fit for me.
OLD MANS BIKE ??? There were many young guys responding to the survey about "What is your age Heritage owners?" I'll bet the woman that made that comment was a teenie bopper whose boyfriend rides a V-Rod. The Heritage is the most classic example of what Harley started out as for the people that love retro and there is no age requirements to own and love them. People that have owned a lot of Harleys usually end up on one. There is a reason for that. " Heritage Forever "
Nothing against the touring bikes, but I'm not a grandpa yet.
I have not looked at prices lately, but when I bought my Fatty in 07 I remember thinking the Heritage was a better value for the money. Then they went and lowered the price of the MSRP on the Fatboy! Anyway, I've always like the Fatboy look. I have removeable accerories for tourning, and it is only a matter of minutes to go from one look to the other. Not sure you can do that with Heritage bags...Plus I love me that fat a$$ 200 tire. Just don't like replacing them every 8-9000 miles.
A new heritage classic is $17,349 in black. A new fatboy is $16,349 in black. So it's $1000 difference. Which is enough for me to weigh the options and say that maybe a fatboy isn't what I'm set on. Unless of course I win the raffle on one! I wouldn't mind that.
In the end I'll have to test em both out before I buy. Maybe even rent one when I really start looking to decide which one I could really see myself behind. But right now I think the fatboy looks mean, and the heritage classic, looks well classy.
#24
#25
#26
#27
Thank you very much! I loved that bike. That was when chrome was king. I was under some harder times then....just divorced, living in an apartment, bills were the main priority...... I put a lot into it and I sold it to a friend. Sadly, he modified it, but at least I sold it to someone I knew.
Not to take away from this thread, I just wanted to cast my vote for the FatBoy. You can do a lot to it.
#28
Heritage gives you that old-school look that I was after. Took off most everything that had studs tho. Not interested in the fully dressed look.
#29
I think it comes down to the look you are going for...they are completely different. I wanted the classic look from the 40's and 50's, so the Heritage was the obvious choice in the Softail line. I happen to love the studded bags (use them everyday), full fenders, and spoked wheels. My choices were between the Heritage and RK Classic. In retrospect, I still like the look/seating position of the Heritage better, but the RK has more capability for the long haul with a passenger. If you don't ride 2-up often, get whatever the hell you want. My biggest recommendation would be to test ride both for a day. That will tell you which one to buy.
#30
I dug the badass look of the Black Fatboy better and this scene kinda sticks in my head whenever I think of my bike
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A_d03QkfhKI&
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A_d03QkfhKI&
Last edited by Totally Bored; 03-09-2012 at 12:10 PM.