I've rode both bikes (and owned a Night Train before I got my Rocker C) and the Night Train is definitely the one for me. For whatever reason, the Fatbob just didn't fit me as good as the Night Train. I'm 5'11", 162lbs. So, if I were choosing, it'd be another Night Train.
i like the softailbut,i aint ridin it YOU are,just make sure its YOU....might even think about lookin at somethin used,already broke in ....RIDE IT LIKE YOU STOLE IT! used is a bit cheaper too if you are havin any doubtsabout which modeli'm also kinda partial to a carb
it is a hard choice for me to make, but looks like the train is going to be more fun on a long run,looks like the train is more mods friendly than the bob....