Ok, time for a poll guys. I just got the Heritage fender on the bike. I don't have any of the trim for it yet but will be picking that up as budget allows.
Vote for which one you like better.

I am really digging the Heritage fender, although, the fatboy loses it's look with this fender. It looks like a Heritage with this fender but I really think it complements the wheel well.

Also, could I JB weld the holes in the fender from the rear and jsut use black touch up to cover the holes? If so will that work of is there a better solution besdies the stock trim? Post up links, or if you ahve stock trim off a fender like this let me know how much you want for it. Thanks...

Heritage fender



Fatboy fender with custom brackets

 

Heritage fender for sure. fatty fenders only work well with fat tires and rins imo.

the heritage fender does a better job covering the wheel.

Lol dude, you shoulda just got a heritage!

Oh, and NO trim on that fender! bondo and fill the holes. Trim would seriously throw the look off. Stipped like that make sit look really slick!

 

+1 on the heritage fender. not even close.

 

heritage fender

 

Sportster fender

 

Has to be one smart azz in the group...

 

I voted fatboy fender..........i like the look ,everyone does the heritage fender.......doesnt hurt to be different......

 

Out of the two the Heritage for sure but I wonder if there is not a better fender for your bike. Nice bike.

 

They both look good but the FB fender sets yours apart.
Tough call.

 

I think the Heritage fender goes really well with the 21 IMO.