Anubiss, From the 2 choices given,I think the Heritage fender looks better,But I would rather like to see a more narrower style of fender that barely hides your outer edge of alum rim..like the ones at these websites.

http://www.tejasthumpcycles.com/Part...tire_22454.jpg
http://www.axiomcycles.com/pages/ite...temsection=201
http://www.axiomcycles.com/pages/ite...temsection=201

 

Its not even close...Heritage. I think it would look even better with the trim and the front end lowered.

 

I like em both!

 

Heritage fender .........No Light trim in the front.

 

I think you should leave the fender trim off and weld up the holes and have it painted by a pro. PLEASE don't "rig" your bike... you've obviousely invested alot of $$ and the fender will definately look like crap up close if you use JB and touch up. You can probably get it done for about $150. Here's mine for inspiration.

 

I just remembered I have a smooth Heritage style fender that would fit your bike that I'm not using. It has no holes and looks just like the one I put on my bike. It's your for FREE if u like.

 

Heritage....the Fatty looks out of place. It fills out alot better and brings everything together.

 

Heritage all the way...

 

Ever get rid of that fender... I'm in need of one...

 

I like the fatty one myself, just so ppl recognise it as a fatty... but if your goin 4 the Heritage, i'd leave it stripped...

D