Milwaukee Eight (M8) 2017 and up M8 Air and Liquid Cooled discussion
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

The truth about removing cat vs. increase flow

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
  #101  
Old 02-15-2023, 12:22 PM
Max Headflow's Avatar
Max Headflow
Max Headflow is online now
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: poway
Posts: 17,262
Received 6,040 Likes on 4,074 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Old New Rider
Thank you for sharing.

Unsurprising to me, at least. Measurable flow difference, not enough to really feel the miniscule torque increase, but added some mpg and cooler leg!

Nice.

Why not a decrease?
 
  #102  
Old 02-15-2023, 02:58 PM
QNman's Avatar
QNman
QNman is offline
Supporter
Join Date: Apr 2015
Location: St. Charles, MO
Posts: 6,856
Received 3,717 Likes on 1,991 Posts
Default

On my 2016, you could slow cook a pot roast on the right passenger footboard until the cat was removed.

On my 2021, I have the 131 and the HD high-flow cats; absolutely no heat issue whatsoever, and my warranty is whole.
 
The following users liked this post:
Old New Rider (02-15-2023)
  #103  
Old 02-15-2023, 04:04 PM
CWOFOR's Avatar
CWOFOR
CWOFOR is offline
Tourer
Join Date: Apr 2017
Location: Menominee, MI
Posts: 361
Received 184 Likes on 100 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by mjwebb
just curious...did you retune after mod, and did you consider adding the Cool Flow fan instead? wondering what felt heat differences might be between cat removal vs cool flow fan... guessing it may be pretty close, and cost wise less expensive adding fan vs buying tuner and Dyno'ed
Did not retune after the mod. My service guy told me because it was the only thing I changed that the ECM would be able to adjust to it, which seemed to be the case for me (no popping, no gurggling, no pingging) none of the stuff you would normally associate with out a retune. No, I didn't consider the fan option as doing the decat was just time to me (I have cutting tools and a welder).
 
  #104  
Old 02-15-2023, 04:58 PM
Old New Rider's Avatar
Old New Rider
Old New Rider is offline
Road Master
Join Date: Nov 2022
Location: MN
Posts: 1,133
Received 349 Likes on 274 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Max Headflow
Why not a decrease?
This is a myth. Engines do not require back pressure to create torque. In fact, they have backpressure limits to prevent excessive loss of torque, and overheating.

Harley doesn't have a magic combustion process different from any other hydrocarbon burning engine. My experience is with development of turbocharged diesel engines, but a number of exhaust suppliers here I've talked to have derided this myth as misinformation.
 
The following users liked this post:
Old Ranger (02-15-2023)
  #105  
Old 02-15-2023, 05:02 PM
mjwebb's Avatar
mjwebb
mjwebb is online now
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: State of Confusion
Posts: 12,417
Received 9,384 Likes on 4,788 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Old New Rider
This is a myth. Engines do not require back pressure to create torque. In fact, they have backpressure limits to prevent excessive loss of torque, and overheating.

Harley doesn't have a magic combustion process different from any other hydrocarbon burning engine. My experience is with development of turbocharged diesel engines, but a number of exhaust suppliers here I've talked to have derided this myth as misinformation.
recall reading up on back pressure in this context, and it being a bit of a misnomer, where really the performance is about velocity, scavenging, baffle diameters..whole bunch of tech stuff I can't fully comprehend..maybe some subject matter experts can expound on it more
 
  #106  
Old 02-15-2023, 07:20 PM
Max Headflow's Avatar
Max Headflow
Max Headflow is online now
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: poway
Posts: 17,262
Received 6,040 Likes on 4,074 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Old New Rider
This is a myth. Engines do not require back pressure to create torque. In fact, they have backpressure limits to prevent excessive loss of torque, and overheating.

Harley doesn't have a magic combustion process different from any other hydrocarbon burning engine. My experience is with development of turbocharged diesel engines, but a number of exhaust suppliers here I've talked to have derided this myth as misinformation.

It's not a myth. Talk to Fuel moto.. With M8 they even see a HP / TQ gain by adding back pressure with certain cams..

I've seen torque go down and HP go up with baffle removal some bikes and the opposite on others.. I have examples of both..

The thing is that it really pretty much depends on everything but mostly cam, compression and exhaust design. If all you are only looking at flow you'll fail.. You have to look at exhaust tuning.

When you turbo charge, it's a whole different ball game..
 
The following users liked this post:
teedoff65 (02-17-2023)
  #107  
Old 02-15-2023, 07:35 PM
Old New Rider's Avatar
Old New Rider
Old New Rider is offline
Road Master
Join Date: Nov 2022
Location: MN
Posts: 1,133
Received 349 Likes on 274 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Max Headflow
It's not a myth. Talk to Fuel moto.. With M8 they even see a HP / TQ gain by adding back pressure with certain cams..

I've seen torque go down and HP go up with baffle removal some bikes and the opposite on others.. I have examples of both..

The thing is that it really pretty much depends on everything but mostly cam, compression and exhaust design. If all you are only looking at flow you'll fail.. You have to look at exhaust tuning.

When you turbo charge, it's a whole different ball game..
First, FM has some issues, ok? Like an "expert" advising you should only shift above 4,000 rpm. A muffler vendor expert on here said it is bunk, as did my own pro builder. There has to be enough backpressure to not encounter reversion, but that is dependent on the diameter and length of each pipe.

Of course you have to look at the system. But increasing exhaust backpressure in general terms does NOT increase engine power output. Period.
 
  #108  
Old 02-15-2023, 07:53 PM
Max Headflow's Avatar
Max Headflow
Max Headflow is online now
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: poway
Posts: 17,262
Received 6,040 Likes on 4,074 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Old New Rider
First, FM has some issues, ok? Like an "expert" advising you should only shift above 4,000 rpm. A muffler vendor expert on here said it is bunk, as did my own pro builder. There has to be enough backpressure to not encounter reversion, but that is dependent on the diameter and length of each pipe.

Of course you have to look at the system. But increasing exhaust backpressure in general terms does NOT increase engine power output. Period.
I thought we were all pro builders here.. So you dis FM because he said something you disagree with? and I supposed to take your word for it?

What about over exhausting? One of the things to note is that you can build a pipe that works perfect but 90% of the time that pipe won't fit..
 
The following users liked this post:
FLTRI17 (02-17-2023)
  #109  
Old 02-17-2023, 08:30 AM
teedoff65's Avatar
teedoff65
teedoff65 is offline
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: High Point, NC.
Posts: 5,680
Received 1,527 Likes on 1,090 Posts
Default

I think I'll trust the guys that are on the forefront of developing tuners, maps, performance upgrades and big bore to racing engines as the go to expert.

I've witnessed firsthand what just removing the noise reduction inserts do to backpressure and reduced low end torque.
 
The following users liked this post:
lp (02-17-2023)
  #110  
Old 02-17-2023, 11:06 AM
Old New Rider's Avatar
Old New Rider
Old New Rider is offline
Road Master
Join Date: Nov 2022
Location: MN
Posts: 1,133
Received 349 Likes on 274 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Max Headflow
I thought we were all pro builders here.. So you dis FM because he said something you disagree with? and I supposed to take your word for it?

What about over exhausting? One of the things to note is that you can build a pipe that works perfect but 90% of the time that pipe won't fit..
I know its wrong. Not only after talking with other sponsors and builders on here, but personal experience hearing epm shifts on the road. The guy was talk ok ang about street racing, not street driving. There is an FM cult on here that believes anything they're told.
and I wouldn't call a single company a sole leader wither.
I've been in engineering 32 years. It's not true. You guys "believe" what you want to.
I'll listen to those on here talking physics and have test data.
 
The following users liked this post:
Just Cruzin' (02-20-2023)


Quick Reply: The truth about removing cat vs. increase flow



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:24 PM.