Nightrider O2 IED's - Field Test
#1991
RE: Nightrider O2 IEDs
ORIGINAL: whittlebeast
The issue is that this is not a true speed density system. Harley uses a Hybrid speed density system.
The issue is that this is not a true speed density system. Harley uses a Hybrid speed density system.
Air flow thru the cylinder is a function of the average pressure on the front side of the intake valve and the back side of the exhaust valve at the time in the crank rotation when the valves are open.
This has a huge effect on the amount of unburnable air left behind on the exhaust stroke and the amount of new fuel needed on the next cycle.
But I know what you are saying, though not necessarily how it correlates with what you had said just previously (maybe it will fall into place when you flesh that out for me).
This system may or may not even have the intake absolute pressure in the basic fuel calc. Throttle position is a poor predictor of air flow let alone the only predictor.
I agree that TPS is a poor singular quantifier, but do not understand or believe it to be used that way currently. Please enlighten me further! Rest assured I want to be right about this, but not at the expense of anyone else. I want us all to be right. Lets get to the very bottom of it.
#1992
RE: Nightrider O2 IEDs
Rider, I answered your most recent PM just before I started on that previous reply above.
I do not want to derail the discussion onto this topic only, but does anyone with access to a Digital Technician setup know what the AFV does for a cylinder immediately after throwing a lean/rich code? Does it stay at its limit and work its way back down or does it immediately revert to a previous, or maybe a preset value, like maybe 100% or something? Please try to catch one live by disconnecting a sensor or maybe increasing or decreasing fuel pressure and let me know, okay?
Thanks.
ORIGINAL: glens
The lean-running error codes occur whenever the system is in closed-loop and the adaptive fuel mechanism has run out of headroom. At the time that happens there is quite a fair amount of extra fuel being sent in an attempt to remedy things.
The lean-running error codes occur whenever the system is in closed-loop and the adaptive fuel mechanism has run out of headroom. At the time that happens there is quite a fair amount of extra fuel being sent in an attempt to remedy things.
Thanks.
#1993
RE: Nightrider O2 IEDs
Speed Density by definition \\;uses the absolute air \\;pressure in the intake times a VE value (correction) \\;that is RPM and MAP \\;based table. \\; The primary component of this VE is a correction to account for the gasses that were left behind by the previous combustion and exhaust event. \\; At low RPM this unburnable \\;gas (as the o2 has been used up) is fairly significant. \\; So at low RPM the VEs are in the 40% range in most true Speed density systems. \\; As you get close to the torque peak a motor tends to get real close to 100% VE. \\; At high RPM the pumping losses in the intake and exhaust tend to roll this VE back off to about 90% VE \\;right before the rev limiter normally sets in. \\; Harley for some reason elected to use a RPM and Throttle position VE map. \\; The MAP pressure either comes from the MAP sensor or from one of the hidden tables known as the Map_Default_Table. \\; The reported MAP value on some of my data loges exceeds the ambient air pressure and unless this is from ram effect of the intake it appears the bike may even be using some sort of synthetic MAP value based on a MAP lookup. \\; Who knows?
 \\;
The air flow into and out of the cylinder is indeed a wild calulation based on pressure differential accross the open valves. \\; Not just the valve overlap. \\; Most EFI systems have a correction table for backpressure in the exhaust that is aggrivated by ambient air pressure. \\; I am working on a system now that goes way past these basic assumptions. \\; It all has to do with "engine modeling".
 \\;
I would love to \\;see \\;a new thread started to allow us to take this up a few orders of magnitude.
 \\;
AW
 \\;
 \\;
 \\;
The air flow into and out of the cylinder is indeed a wild calulation based on pressure differential accross the open valves. \\; Not just the valve overlap. \\; Most EFI systems have a correction table for backpressure in the exhaust that is aggrivated by ambient air pressure. \\; I am working on a system now that goes way past these basic assumptions. \\; It all has to do with "engine modeling".
 \\;
I would love to \\;see \\;a new thread started to allow us to take this up a few orders of magnitude.
 \\;
AW
 \\;
 \\;
#1994
RE: Nightrider O2 IEDs
So if i'm not getting codes, my Xied's are not working? \\; I have seen no codes, but i'm getting some popping on decel only. \\; I'm running stock a/c and rush 2.0's on my FXDF. \\; I have 1600 miles and put syn3 in for my 1000 mile service. \\; Runs much better, but that popping has been bothering me. \\; I ordered the PCIII and a big sucker A/C. \\; Can i run the PCIII and Xied's together?
Thanks.
Thanks.
#1995
RE: Nightrider O2 IEDs
Okay, I am following you so far. Looking forward to some face time.
Several orders of clean magnitude!
About the wild calculation, all my handheld calculators use either RPN or RPL. Bring it on! I will save a bunch of keystrokes over an algebraic-entry-laden device...
ORIGINAL: whittlebeast
The air flow into and out of the cylinder is indeed a wild calulation based on pressure differential accross the open valves.
...
I would love to see a new thread started to allow us to take this up a few orders of magnitude.
The air flow into and out of the cylinder is indeed a wild calulation based on pressure differential accross the open valves.
...
I would love to see a new thread started to allow us to take this up a few orders of magnitude.
About the wild calculation, all my handheld calculators use either RPN or RPL. Bring it on! I will save a bunch of keystrokes over an algebraic-entry-laden device...
#1996
RE: Nightrider O2 IEDs
ORIGINAL: MNrider
I ordered the PCIII and a big sucker A/C. Can i run the PCIII and Xied's together?
I ordered the PCIII and a big sucker A/C. Can i run the PCIII and Xied's together?
In one sense this site is really, really, unreal. Sorry, MNrider, nothing personal. There are relatively few fundamental things to learn about this engine management stuff and there is no way in hell I would personally even try much of what I see being talked about here without first learning the fundamentals. To me, $20,000 for a motorcycle precludes wild speculation concerning its well-being.
#1997
RE: Nightrider O2 IEDs
MNrider,
 \\;
Just because your not getting codes does not mean your XIEDs are not working. \\; You should be able to tell the difference in ridability when they are on. \\; If you do suspect they are not working see nightriders website. \\; He explains a test to do to check them. \\;
As far as the PCIII goes, it may be possible, but the way the PCIII is designed to work is by eliiminating the 02 sensors alltogether, with the use of supplied 02 eliminators. \\; Since the XIEDs go inline with the 02 sensors, you would be negating the whole design of the PCIII. \\; Unless your a whiz at mapping and have your own dynometer it probably is not recommended.
 \\;
Just because your not getting codes does not mean your XIEDs are not working. \\; You should be able to tell the difference in ridability when they are on. \\; If you do suspect they are not working see nightriders website. \\; He explains a test to do to check them. \\;
As far as the PCIII goes, it may be possible, but the way the PCIII is designed to work is by eliiminating the 02 sensors alltogether, with the use of supplied 02 eliminators. \\; Since the XIEDs go inline with the 02 sensors, you would be negating the whole design of the PCIII. \\; Unless your a whiz at mapping and have your own dynometer it probably is not recommended.
#1999
RE: Nightrider O2 IEDs
ORIGINAL: glens
Rider, I answered your most recent PM just before I started on that previous reply above.
I do not want to derail the discussion onto this topic only, but does anyone with access to a Digital Technician setup know what the AFV does for a cylinder immediately after throwing a lean/rich code? Does it stay at its limit and work its way back down or does it immediately revert to a previous, or maybe a preset value, like maybe 100% or something? Please try to catch one live by disconnecting a sensor or maybe increasing or decreasing fuel pressure and let me know, okay?
Thanks.
Rider, I answered your most recent PM just before I started on that previous reply above.
ORIGINAL: glens
The lean-running error codes occur whenever the system is in closed-loop and the adaptive fuel mechanism has run out of headroom. At the time that happens there is quite a fair amount of extra fuel being sent in an attempt to remedy things.
The lean-running error codes occur whenever the system is in closed-loop and the adaptive fuel mechanism has run out of headroom. At the time that happens there is quite a fair amount of extra fuel being sent in an attempt to remedy things.
Thanks.
#2000
RE: Nightrider O2 IEDs
The AFV goes to 90% Does that mean the the entire map is leaned out by X times .9 or you end up leaner with any one of those inputs disconnected?
 \\;
That matches what I got when I disconnected my o2s and data logged the results. \\;The \\;PW did get leaner by about 90% of the original PW. I wonder why they do that?
 \\;
 \\;
AW
 \\;
 \\;
 \\;
That matches what I got when I disconnected my o2s and data logged the results. \\;The \\;PW did get leaner by about 90% of the original PW. I wonder why they do that?
 \\;
 \\;
AW
 \\;
 \\;