Question: Carb or Injected?
#51
You can keep FI and everything associated with it. I'm going riding on my bike with the advanced toilet that delivers fuel in a manner that I have set it up to do and while doing so I will be spending the money I saved on gas, which allows me to ride even further....
https://www.hdforums.com/forum/4175660-post1.html
#52
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Simpson County Kentucky
Posts: 1,775
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
Doesn't your 2004 Yamaha FZ6 have FI? You stated it has run flawlessly, so I dont' know what all the fuss is about.
https://www.hdforums.com/forum/4175660-post1.html
https://www.hdforums.com/forum/4175660-post1.html
The problem I have here is the same problem that always comes up when people start saying things like FI starts better, or FI gets better fuel mileage, or FI has fewer malfunctions. I've seen shortcomings on both sides. I would agree that stock for stock, the FI is generally smoother in most cases however, when the carb bike gets dialed in and jetted properly, which it isn't from the factory, it is pretty much fool proof and if maintained properly very rarely malfunctions. In contrast, I have had two OBDII vehicles that were injected which have had injector failures and one that while operating flawlessly has a current recall. I had a CJ7 that was carbed and went 20 years before I sold it on the same carb with not one malfunction and that Jeep got put through pure hell during its lifespan.
#54
Yes, the FZ does have injection (the only bike I have with injection) and if I followed the letters Yamaha International has sent to me it too would have been in the shop to have an issue they recalled repaired. However, I have spoken with the local dealer to let them know I am still the owner and have yet to experience the problem they want to fix so no recall fix for me because it has operated flawlessly and contued to do so when I went for a ride today at 28 degrees. Apparently others have not been so lucky, which is why they had a recall. Take this one step further and you will find they redesigned that injection system in 2007 to remidy the malfunction forever.
The problem I have here is the same problem that always comes up when people start saying things like FI starts better, or FI gets better fuel mileage, or FI has fewer malfunctions. I've seen shortcomings on both sides. I would agree that stock for stock, the FI is generally smoother in most cases however, when the carb bike gets dialed in and jetted properly, which it isn't from the factory, it is pretty much fool proof and if maintained properly very rarely malfunctions. In contrast, I have had two OBDII vehicles that were injected which have had injector failures and one that while operating flawlessly has a current recall. I had a CJ7 that was carbed and went 20 years before I sold it on the same carb with not one malfunction and that Jeep got put through pure hell during its lifespan.
The problem I have here is the same problem that always comes up when people start saying things like FI starts better, or FI gets better fuel mileage, or FI has fewer malfunctions. I've seen shortcomings on both sides. I would agree that stock for stock, the FI is generally smoother in most cases however, when the carb bike gets dialed in and jetted properly, which it isn't from the factory, it is pretty much fool proof and if maintained properly very rarely malfunctions. In contrast, I have had two OBDII vehicles that were injected which have had injector failures and one that while operating flawlessly has a current recall. I had a CJ7 that was carbed and went 20 years before I sold it on the same carb with not one malfunction and that Jeep got put through pure hell during its lifespan.
#55
I've owned both, and they both have their benefits. Carbs are cheaper to tune and when something goes wrong with one, you can still usually still limp home. On FI if it breaks you’re done! Get towed and it’s expensive to tune. However I currently have FI and have about 30000 miles on the bike with no problems. It starts easier, runs smoother, gets better mileage, and makes more power than carbed bikes. So is the trade off worth it? I'll let you know after it leaves me stranded somewhere.
Last edited by 1Coastie; 02-17-2009 at 12:09 PM.
#56
Mines carbed, the next one will be FI. While I'm sitting there fooling with the choke and worried about running it too long and fouling plugs and then having to stand there and keep a hand on the thropttle, my FI friends are putting on jackets and waloking around. Mine has to warm up to run good, theirs does from cold starts. Their mileage is a little better.
Fi is the only way to go for my money (and it will be )
Bubba
Fi is the only way to go for my money (and it will be )
Bubba
#57
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Land of the Free, Home of Jack Daniel's
Posts: 46,829
Received 21,353 Likes
on
8,411 Posts