Car oil vs motorcycle oil
#41
Motorcycle oil is fairly new,to me anyway.When I first started riding Harleys there was only car oil.It may have said something else on the cans but it was car oil.Think about all the aircooled motors out there using car oil.
#42
The bigger thing to me is not whether it's motorcycle or car oil but rather the frequency of the oil change. Keep it changed on schedule and you should be ok.
Bubba
Bubba
#44
I find that if I pour in about a half quart of warm bacon grease with every oil change it really seems to make it run right. Smells tasty when it's running too...
I use regular Royal Purple 20w50 in my bike with no troubles. I know it is far superior to the dino that it was shipped from the factory with and from researching online I have concluded that it isn't worth it to pay nearly twice the price for the max cycle stuff. I still use regular old HD primary oil because it isn't as much of a high intensity application as the engine (found supporting info here on the forum). In the tranny I am currently running Red Line Shock Proof Heavy gear oil and the viscosity is escaping me as I am a little intoxicated at the moment. I change the engine oil more frequently than the others so that is where I'm most concerned with saving money. $11 a quart can be a hard pill to swallow when you're broke.
I use regular Royal Purple 20w50 in my bike with no troubles. I know it is far superior to the dino that it was shipped from the factory with and from researching online I have concluded that it isn't worth it to pay nearly twice the price for the max cycle stuff. I still use regular old HD primary oil because it isn't as much of a high intensity application as the engine (found supporting info here on the forum). In the tranny I am currently running Red Line Shock Proof Heavy gear oil and the viscosity is escaping me as I am a little intoxicated at the moment. I change the engine oil more frequently than the others so that is where I'm most concerned with saving money. $11 a quart can be a hard pill to swallow when you're broke.
#45
At the risk of pissing all ya'll off If I run some oil, speced for a gasoline cage, that ya'll say is ok to use in either bike, will you pay for the necessary repairs if it fails? If you are, let me know and I will give it a shot. Just want the repair costs up front. Come on guys, you will spend a bunch on chrome but think you need to skimp on oil. And FYI it was 23.21 for a chrome filter (9.00) and 3 quarts 0f HD oil for my sporty. What's that? 4 something a quart? Big deal
#46
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Simpson County Kentucky
Posts: 1,775
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
Although I would agree with crapshooter, as he mentioned the same things I did concerning MCNews and friction modifiers, the MCNews testing is now over 15 years old, and many oils on the market today didn't even exist back then (such as Harley's Syn 3), so there may be "improvements" in new oils that are beneficial.
There was another series of articles around 2000 in American Iron called "Oil Wars." It was very direct in stating that there was nothing special about a Harley engine that required a "special" oil, as Harley liked to claim. It was only a few years ago that Harley finally endorsed synthetic oil, but only after introducing and marketing their own Syn 3.
There was another series of articles around 2000 in American Iron called "Oil Wars." It was very direct in stating that there was nothing special about a Harley engine that required a "special" oil, as Harley liked to claim. It was only a few years ago that Harley finally endorsed synthetic oil, but only after introducing and marketing their own Syn 3.
#47
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Simpson County Kentucky
Posts: 1,775
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
At the risk of pissing all ya'll off If I run some oil, speced for a gasoline cage, that ya'll say is ok to use in either bike, will you pay for the necessary repairs if it fails? If you are, let me know and I will give it a shot. Just want the repair costs up front. Come on guys, you will spend a bunch on chrome but think you need to skimp on oil. And FYI it was 23.21 for a chrome filter (9.00) and 3 quarts 0f HD oil for my sporty. What's that? 4 something a quart? Big deal
#49
I would think motorcycles with water cooled radiators and oil coolers could use car oil without to much concern, being cautious of particular automotive additives etc... I think I've read somewhere that motorcycle specific oil has a higher viscosity resistence to break down to heat then car oil.
And in a pinch, any oil is better then no oil. If I needed to top off or what ever and there was no motorcycle oil I would without blinking put in a similar SAE car oil as I was using. But when ever possible I will always try to use MOCO oil.
#50
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Simpson County Kentucky
Posts: 1,775
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
+1.
I would think motorcycles with water cooled radiators and oil coolers could use car oil without to much concern, being cautious of particular automotive additives etc... I think I've read somewhere that motorcycle specific oil has a higher viscosity resistence to break down to heat then car oil.
And in a pinch, any oil is better then no oil. If I needed to top off or what ever and there was no motorcycle oil I would without blinking put in a similar SAE car oil as I was using. But when ever possible I will always try to use MOCO oil.
I would think motorcycles with water cooled radiators and oil coolers could use car oil without to much concern, being cautious of particular automotive additives etc... I think I've read somewhere that motorcycle specific oil has a higher viscosity resistence to break down to heat then car oil.
And in a pinch, any oil is better then no oil. If I needed to top off or what ever and there was no motorcycle oil I would without blinking put in a similar SAE car oil as I was using. But when ever possible I will always try to use MOCO oil.