What part in WI are you. I bet these guys here in Sheboygan can do it for you. They are great and do lots of bike and hot rod stuff. Give a look and call them.
http://www.classiccoatings.com/

 

I thought about doing the same thing to mine and the pc i was talking to said he'd use black model paint to fill it in.

 

problem is masking the little dimples is not an easy task... near impossible even to finger wipe... granted we have polished and 2 toned wheels you name it... we are a forum sponsor and more than happy to help any way we can... here are some of the wheels we have done for members







polilshed black centers and total wheel cleared









this guy was looking for a 2 tone as well this is what we came up with him instead
of the dimples