Comparing Harley-Davidson Street Glide and the Indian Chieftain
#11
#12
I owned a Chieftain and now own the Street Glide so I didn't bother to read the comparison. My Street Glide is more fun to ride and handles as well as the Chieftain. The Street Glide wins for looks and for fit and finish and the Milwaukee 8 is a more spirited engine. I miss some of the features my Chieftain had such as, the locking hard bags and adjustable windshield but I can easily live without them. Suspension was slightly better on the Chieftain but it was an inconvenience to have to keep the proper pressure in the air shock and mine always seemed to lose air. of course the dealer could never find anything wrong with it.
I always thought that I would end up back on an Indian but now I have my doubts and am perfectly content where I am at and I've put far more miles on both models to know what the better bike is and I currently own it. Next summer I'll be trading in my street glide for a Road Glide Ultra.
Looking at the photo's you can definitely see that Indian is go after the Street Glide. Really hard to tell them apart when you see them coming in the opposite direction.
I always thought that I would end up back on an Indian but now I have my doubts and am perfectly content where I am at and I've put far more miles on both models to know what the better bike is and I currently own it. Next summer I'll be trading in my street glide for a Road Glide Ultra.
Looking at the photo's you can definitely see that Indian is go after the Street Glide. Really hard to tell them apart when you see them coming in the opposite direction.
#13
Thank you for this. There is more useful information in your post than in the original article. There is an Indian dealership across the street from my Harley dealership. I am a bit curious. I honestly have no intentions of buying an Indian, and I'd hate to waste their time asking for a test ride.
#14
Join Date: Oct 2015
Location: Pine Flat Dam/South Bay Area, CA
Posts: 12,009
Received 24,560 Likes
on
7,973 Posts
#15
My first bike was a cafe racer...a BMW r90s. My second was a BMW r1200c. 480lbs and about 520lbs respectively. I understand how you feel. I used to look at my brother's big HDs and say the same thing. I love how my Street Glide rides and responds.
The following users liked this post:
SWFLGuy (08-02-2019)
#16
#17
The following 2 users liked this post by victory11:
Halojumper (08-02-2019),
s-glide76 (08-01-2019)
#18
Inverted forks, monoshock suspension, aluminum frame, and a 120 HP liquid cooled engine. It's a dead ringer for a RG. There is much more to a motorcycle than a paint job and a fairing. I haven't seen the finished product but I bet it's going to ride smooth and handle pretty well.
Good. I'm glad Indian is doing this because it will ultimately force HD to update its Touring frame and suspension in order to remain competitive. Whether HD will develop a liquid-cooled version of the M8 is anyone's guess, but that time is coming as well.
Competition improves the products.
The following users liked this post:
Sparky357 (08-02-2019)
#19
Good. I'm glad Indian is doing this because it will ultimately force HD to update its Touring frame and suspension in order to remain competitive. Whether HD will develop a liquid-cooled version of the M8 is anyone's guess, but that time is coming as well.
Competition improves the products.
Competition improves the products.
#20
I demoed the chieftain at bike week this year and came away unimpressed. I wanted to like it, and honestly I did, but not for the money. It feels like a cheaper copy of the harley, but instead it's a similarly priced copy of the harley.
I did like the infotainment screen and the adjustable windshield was cool but I doubted I would ever actually adjust it once I found the spot I liked. I also think the windshield is just one more thing that can fail, and the aftermarket options can't be as competitive as a standard fit windshield like the harley.
The suspension felt a little firmer and the brakes left much to be desired, power was on par with harley m8. The throttle was very loose, like it had no resistance when turning, which made slow speed maneuvers a little more difficult.
Fit and finish is what made me think a cheaper copy. It just doesn't feel as nice if that makes sense. The switches, mirrors, and other odd and end things just feel cheaper made and I'm not sure how long term they would hold up.
Overall if the bikes was 5k or more under the cost of a comparable street glide, I would consider one. Otherwise I believe the street glide is the nicer looking, feeling, and riding motorcycle.
I did like the infotainment screen and the adjustable windshield was cool but I doubted I would ever actually adjust it once I found the spot I liked. I also think the windshield is just one more thing that can fail, and the aftermarket options can't be as competitive as a standard fit windshield like the harley.
The suspension felt a little firmer and the brakes left much to be desired, power was on par with harley m8. The throttle was very loose, like it had no resistance when turning, which made slow speed maneuvers a little more difficult.
Fit and finish is what made me think a cheaper copy. It just doesn't feel as nice if that makes sense. The switches, mirrors, and other odd and end things just feel cheaper made and I'm not sure how long term they would hold up.
Overall if the bikes was 5k or more under the cost of a comparable street glide, I would consider one. Otherwise I believe the street glide is the nicer looking, feeling, and riding motorcycle.