View Poll Results: Which is better in general? Garmin Zumo's or the HD Built-In GPS?
HD is WAY, WAY better!
1
1.49%
HD is better.
4
5.97%
They are about the same. Pro's 'n Con's with each.
20
29.85%
GARMIN Zumo's are better.
20
29.85%
GARMIN Zumo's are WAY, WAY better.
22
32.84%
Voters: 67. You may not vote on this poll
Which is better? GARMIN or HD Built-In GPS?
#31
Last edited by skratch; 12-31-2016 at 09:35 PM.
#32
I'm a play with it first and decide if I like it, if I do then I'll go back and read the manuals. Well now that I've read the manual and played with it a bit more as it is sitting in the garage I may end up liking it.
I do believe the avoid freeways was checked as I just unchecked it. Had to of been done and the dealership because I just learned. O'well!!!
I do believe the avoid freeways was checked as I just unchecked it. Had to of been done and the dealership because I just learned. O'well!!!
The following users liked this post:
BuzzCap7 (01-05-2017)
#34
The Boom system will get you from point A to point B every time. The inherent problem with the software is that no one at HD seemed to realize that most motorcycle riders ride to NOT go DIRECTLY from point A to point B and instead want to take an exact route on very particular roads.
The Boom system is extremely temperamental and quirky to operate this way to the point of being useless in my opinion. I have screwed around with it for hours and have never had a ride I planned on the computer work out exactly in real life.
I no longer use the boom unit at all. I would tear it out if could and put a gum dispenser in its place.
I now use Google Maps on my Android. On you desktop, you can create a single route with multiple destinations and then send it to your phone. You cannot create it on your phone (yet). It works great and the interface is a gazillion times better than the slow HD one that names roads awkwardly (as in a road name or street name will show up five different ways in the list you pick from in the menus).
No GPS is perfect but the HD one is abysmal.
What I look for is can I set an exact route on computer tonight and push it to the the GPS to ride tomorrow without changes (or creating 200 waypoints).
The Boom system is extremely temperamental and quirky to operate this way to the point of being useless in my opinion. I have screwed around with it for hours and have never had a ride I planned on the computer work out exactly in real life.
I no longer use the boom unit at all. I would tear it out if could and put a gum dispenser in its place.
I now use Google Maps on my Android. On you desktop, you can create a single route with multiple destinations and then send it to your phone. You cannot create it on your phone (yet). It works great and the interface is a gazillion times better than the slow HD one that names roads awkwardly (as in a road name or street name will show up five different ways in the list you pick from in the menus).
No GPS is perfect but the HD one is abysmal.
What I look for is can I set an exact route on computer tonight and push it to the the GPS to ride tomorrow without changes (or creating 200 waypoints).
#35
While the Garmin Zumo is still the best, the Boom isn't that bad. I've planned many trips that include dozens and dozens of turns into the Boom and it has hit every turn, you just need to zoom in and double check every waypoint in Ride Planner (I like MotoGoLoco). I like the layout and additional features that the Zumo offers, but haven't used it since I got my Boom bike.
Anybody who says "use your phone" has never planned a route that that can have 50 different turns in 100 miles. And for those that just ride don't realize the small, short, twisty, country roads that they pass. Zoom into Google maps and look around you'll be amazed by the roads you ride right by.
Anybody who says "use your phone" has never planned a route that that can have 50 different turns in 100 miles. And for those that just ride don't realize the small, short, twisty, country roads that they pass. Zoom into Google maps and look around you'll be amazed by the roads you ride right by.
The following 3 users liked this post by Beertapper:
#36
While the Garmin Zumo is still the best, the Boom isn't that bad. I've planned many trips that include dozens and dozens of turns into the Boom and it has hit every turn, you just need to zoom in and double check every waypoint in Ride Planner (I like MotoGoLoco). I like the layout and additional features that the Zumo offers, but haven't used it since I got my Boom bike.
Anybody who says "use your phone" has never planned a route that that can have 50 different turns in 100 miles. And for those that just ride don't realize the small, short, twisty, country roads that they pass. Zoom into Google maps and look around you'll be amazed by the roads you ride right by.
Anybody who says "use your phone" has never planned a route that that can have 50 different turns in 100 miles. And for those that just ride don't realize the small, short, twisty, country roads that they pass. Zoom into Google maps and look around you'll be amazed by the roads you ride right by.
I will never take a long trip with out my zumo finding all the best roads and roadside attractions is very easy to do from home\google.
The following users liked this post:
BuzzCap7 (01-08-2017)
#37
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Lafayette, Louisiana
Posts: 22,145
Received 15,815 Likes
on
6,704 Posts
Looking at these replies, it seems like it comes down to what a person knows how to use and what his preferences are. The negatives of everything listed can be overcome if somebody wants to learn.
I think the only two negatives are price and obsolescence.
Price is a subjective thing but when something costs eight times as much as a similar product, it is hard to imagine it being eight times better. It might ge a little better, but eight times better would be quite a feat.
Regarding obsolescence, that is the number one negative of a built in system that is part of the bike. It's irrelevant if you only keep a bike a couple of years, but if you keep a bike a long time, electronics change and become obsolete at a much quicker pace than the rest of the bike, such as engine etc.
Regardless of anything else, I have always found my most memorable rides were not planned and were more akin to exploring, with GPS mostly being used to locate gas stations, and even then, that is just a relatively recent thing for me, as I used to just have to rely on my wits.
I think the only two negatives are price and obsolescence.
Price is a subjective thing but when something costs eight times as much as a similar product, it is hard to imagine it being eight times better. It might ge a little better, but eight times better would be quite a feat.
Regarding obsolescence, that is the number one negative of a built in system that is part of the bike. It's irrelevant if you only keep a bike a couple of years, but if you keep a bike a long time, electronics change and become obsolete at a much quicker pace than the rest of the bike, such as engine etc.
Regardless of anything else, I have always found my most memorable rides were not planned and were more akin to exploring, with GPS mostly being used to locate gas stations, and even then, that is just a relatively recent thing for me, as I used to just have to rely on my wits.
The following users liked this post:
BuzzCap7 (01-08-2017)
#38
I haven't used the built-in bike GPS systems, but I hate the built-in in my Ford F150. It won't let me do anything while in motion. Also, when I enter information, I have to wait for it to "think" after every key entry before I type the next letter or number. I hate the damn thing. If the bike built-ins are like that, I would use my Garmin. I use the Garmin on my bike (with a Ram mount) and I also use the Garmin in my truck when I go on a longer trip.
For the GPS scoffers, it's not just about figuring out how to get somewhere, it's also about finding food, gas, detours and hotels while on the move. Let's face it, while you are riding it is a bit too windy to unfold a map. Besides, who has a free hand? The Garmin will also alert me to delays along the route and calculate alternatives for my consideration. I also like that the GPS tells me the time to the next via point or destination. Helps me decide if I need to stop for a whiz before getting there.
For the GPS scoffers, it's not just about figuring out how to get somewhere, it's also about finding food, gas, detours and hotels while on the move. Let's face it, while you are riding it is a bit too windy to unfold a map. Besides, who has a free hand? The Garmin will also alert me to delays along the route and calculate alternatives for my consideration. I also like that the GPS tells me the time to the next via point or destination. Helps me decide if I need to stop for a whiz before getting there.
#40