I changed my preferences for subscription notifications from "instant email notification" to "no email notification" yesterday and my email inbox is still getting notifications for replies to threads I've subscribed to. Am I missing something?

 

When you changed the option to stop getting e-mail, did you scroll down to the bottom and click "save"?

 

You had about fifteen pages of subscribed threads that had to be deleted.

 

I didn't realize there was a limit. I was pissed when I logged in and saw they were all gone. Am I still set up to automatically subscribe when I reply, just not receive an email notification when someone replies?

Or are you meaning that even tho I changed my email notification preference, that would only apply to future threads I subscribed to?