Engine Mechanical Topics Discussion for motor builds, cams, head work, stripped bolts and other engine related issues. The good and the bad. If it goes round and around or up and down, post it here.

Flaking piston

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
  #11  
Old 08-28-2021, 10:26 PM
t150vej's Avatar
t150vej
t150vej is offline
HDF Community Team
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: NC USA
Posts: 4,576
Received 1,821 Likes on 1,182 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Max Headflow
You could be right but when I see vertical stripes and no cross hatch, I get suspicious. The reflection is so good it kind of makes me wonder. Maybe there is a light coat of oil masking the cross hatch. Doing stone is like old guys arguing about which bourbon they like best. IMO Your honing would be good if you went real close to finish with the 150s and only knocked the peaks off with the 280s. I finish with 220s but do a quick brush hone (plateau). It leaves a cross hatch that won't go away. Good if there is too much timing and fuel..

I'd almost believe that what ever you got in the fuel might have been corrosive. (Hydrazine )

I might have been a sharp edge on the top of the bore but I doubt it.

Anyway..
LOL. That's actually what I did with the front, but knocked the peaks of with the 280s. I'll look and measure these again before I decide whether to ball or straight home them going back.

I used to buy factory pre sized OEM cylinder kits when Zanotti was selling HD online. I swear the first pair I got looked like dull chrome that'd been rubbed with a brillo pad, compared to all I'd ever seen. Measured one and couldn't believe it. Clearance was right at .00075 but they worked well.

I hope it's a sharp edge. I've built quite a few with cast pistons over the years. Have personally run mine with intake leaks, too much fuel, or timed 2 degrees high (by mistake) and every other f-up you can imagine for way too many miles at a time, but I've never had one do this to a piston, regardless of the abuse.

Pass the popcorn....

 
  #12  
Old 08-29-2021, 05:00 AM
eighteight's Avatar
eighteight
eighteight is offline
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Oct 2019
Location: OH
Posts: 7,900
Received 5,015 Likes on 2,869 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Max Headflow
I'd almost believe that what ever you got in the fuel might have been corrosive. (Hydrazine )
I would think that would effect both cylinders. ( ?)
 
The following users liked this post:
98hotrodfatboy (08-29-2021)
  #13  
Old 08-29-2021, 07:33 AM
98hotrodfatboy's Avatar
98hotrodfatboy
98hotrodfatboy is online now
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Poolville
Posts: 18,294
Received 5,445 Likes on 3,632 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by t150vej
No I don't right now hotrod. Not sure my old hands can hold still enough anymore to take a good one.

Front runs almost perfectly clean and the rear shows some faint (fuel) color on a 60 mile ride, installed with engine hot. (Reading a new plug after been on a cold start with CV is a waste of time). Anneal line center of bend on strap and full turn of color on the base. Did get black oil specks when it first started pinging, but not since that first time. Never did find any silver specks but didn't look too hard. They either there or out the pipe I figure.
Of coarse the latest plugs won't tell us much about the combustion but how about the plugs that were in the bike prior to the 60 mile run? Take the best pic you can..
 
  #14  
Old 08-29-2021, 11:15 AM
t150vej's Avatar
t150vej
t150vej is offline
HDF Community Team
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: NC USA
Posts: 4,576
Received 1,821 Likes on 1,182 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by 98hotrodfatboy
Of coarse the latest plugs won't tell us much about the combustion but how about the plugs that were in the bike prior to the 60 mile run? Take the best pic you can..
I'll try to hook you up with plug photos in a day or 2, Hotrod.

Back to Eds thought about timing, I recently emailed Dyna with a few simple questions. During all that I mentioned I'd always run the module on dual fire since '09, but I have it wired to a single fire coil. He couldn't or wouldn't say why, but did say he was "very concerned" about that.

I had a front wrist pin stick in the rod 3 years ago (another story - I know why) and put in Wisecos and they were good for a while, but engine got so noisy I couldn't stand it when it was warmed up is why I put these cast OEM pistons in last month. Forged will take WAY more timing and a/f abuse than cast and they didn't look bad at all, despite more running clearance I thought they should have.

Got me to thinking. Wired to single fire coil but switch on dual fire - what if the module is freaking out occasionally or has become damaged. Or maybe the wasted spark is happening at the wrong time or wrong cylinder, thinking it's hooked to a stock coil but the blue wire is in the circuit. It would only take an occasional and inaudible pre-ign or det to eventually cause a problem. So on the last rides it was set to single fire and the 20-30 miles after the regular fuel (50/50 93/87 at that point) was not too bad. Only pinged around 55 (2500rpm) on very slight throttle.

Of course the damage is already done and the piston will continue erode and cause a problem regardless, even if everything else is perfect so I know what has to happen there. But I'm really wondering if maybe this was the cause of the excessive engine noise with the Wisecos in the first place and the quick destruction of this rear cast piston.
 
  #15  
Old 08-29-2021, 02:24 PM
Max Headflow's Avatar
Max Headflow
Max Headflow is online now
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: poway
Posts: 17,212
Received 5,992 Likes on 4,054 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by eighteight
I would think that would effect both cylinders. ( ?)
Yeah, I missed that. How about crappy piston casting? HD pistons are hypereutectic. Not an even mix in the metal?

Could simply be too much timing and bad gas. Rear cylinder runs hotter. I generally don't consider a manifold leak unless the idle is real crappy.
 
  #16  
Old 08-29-2021, 02:40 PM
Max Headflow's Avatar
Max Headflow
Max Headflow is online now
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: poway
Posts: 17,212
Received 5,992 Likes on 4,054 Posts
Default

Back to Eds thought about timing, I recently emailed Dyna with a few simple questions. During all that I mentioned I'd always run the module on dual fire since '09, but I have it wired to a single fire coil. He couldn't or wouldn't say why, but did say he was "very concerned" about that.
If running dual fire the rear cylinder would be running like a dual fire system don't know what the front does. Coils / timing should be OK on the rear as it pretty much the same as running a dual fire coil. It might cause module overheating if it wasn't set up for it. Might only be a problem is running a 2000Ki. If it's external, I'd think it would be OK.
 
  #17  
Old 08-29-2021, 02:43 PM
98hotrodfatboy's Avatar
98hotrodfatboy
98hotrodfatboy is online now
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Poolville
Posts: 18,294
Received 5,445 Likes on 3,632 Posts
Default

Hold it, You replaced forged pistons in an Evo where you should have .004-.0045" clearance as per Wiseco and then installed cast pistons in the same bore.. Not good..? You can get away with .003" clearance but that would be the Max.. Maybe that's your problem... Poor fit piston to cylinder......

And as for running a single fire coil on a dual fire setup is not an issue. The other way around and it wouldn't run.. One cylinder would be dead..
 

Last edited by 98hotrodfatboy; 08-29-2021 at 02:58 PM.
  #18  
Old 08-29-2021, 03:38 PM
t150vej's Avatar
t150vej
t150vej is offline
HDF Community Team
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: NC USA
Posts: 4,576
Received 1,821 Likes on 1,182 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by 98hotrodfatboy
Hold it, You replaced forged pistons in an Evo where you should have .004-.0045" clearance as per Wiseco and then installed cast pistons in the same bore.. Not good..? You can get away with .003" clearance but that would be the Max.. Maybe that's your problem... Poor fir piston to cylinder......

And as for running a single fire coil on a dual fire setup is not an issue. The other way around and it wouldn't run.. One cylinder would be dead..
No no. Started with OEM std. Front wrist pin stuck in rod and knocked. (long story why, another time maybe) That hammered the bottom of the front cylinder enough I couldn't hone it out for a std cast piston. So I put in Wiseco std at about .00029 and they still looked great on the shirts after 16k miles. Honed out to 3.503 for the current +.005 OEM pistons.

Dual fire ignition can be run on a single fire coil. Just run a jumper across the two primary trigger posts of the coil. This is an early version of an Ultima nose cone module. It has a single fire coil. I've most always run it with the switch on dual fire but the blue wire is connected to the coil instead of just the pink wire and a jumper. Single fire ignition on a dual fire coil, just use the pink wire only. Single fire ignition/single fire coil, use pink for rear and blue for front.
http://www.ultimaproducts.com/53-644_ignition.pdf

Originally Posted by Max Headflow
Yeah, I missed that. How about crappy piston casting? HD pistons are hypereutectic. Not an even mix in the metal?

Could simply be too much timing and bad gas. Rear cylinder runs hotter. I generally don't consider a manifold leak unless the idle is real crappy.
Simply a bad piston was at the bottom of my list, but certainly a possibility. Only thing I've ever know to flake one is high heat. Whether from timing or a/f or pressure, heat is the killer. Put one in a toaster oven sometime and set it to "dark" and see what happens - real quick. I've done it... don't ask

Originally Posted by Max Headflow
If running dual fire the rear cylinder would be running like a dual fire system don't know what the front does. Coils / timing should be OK on the rear as it pretty much the same as running a dual fire coil. It might cause module overheating if it wasn't set up for it. Might only be a problem is running a 2000Ki. If it's external, I'd think it would be OK.
I'm just sorta grabbing at straws as to why the timing might be weird (at times) even though the install sheets say all switches off to time with a light (which makes it dual fire) regardless of the coil(s) setup. Well, that's how I've run it for years. Wired for single fire, but module switch on dual fire. So obviously the blue wire sends a signal regardless of whether set to single or dual fire. Even before the current smoked piston, it occasionally seemed like it was clacking, or pinging or something. Chalked it up to Evo normal.

Yeah, it's an old one - 53-642




Wired like this
------------------------------------------------------------




 
  #19  
Old 08-29-2021, 05:10 PM
Max Headflow's Avatar
Max Headflow
Max Headflow is online now
Seasoned HDF Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: poway
Posts: 17,212
Received 5,992 Likes on 4,054 Posts
Default

Dual fire ignition can be run on a single fire coil. Just run a jumper across the two primary trigger posts of the coil.
I don't think it's a good idea to do that. The module sees 1 1/2 ohms instead of 3.
 
  #20  
Old 08-29-2021, 07:58 PM
Since 1968's Avatar
Since 1968
Since 1968 is offline
Road Master
Join Date: Jun 2019
Location: Richmond TX
Posts: 886
Received 458 Likes on 304 Posts
Default

Interesting thread! This may not (and should not) matter, but one thing that distinguishes the rear cylinder from the front cylinder is the timing of the wasted spark. Normally the rear cylinder gets that 'extra' spark before the intake valve opens so there's no real effect on anything. I wonder whether that would be true if some air/fuel mix was slipping through..... Maybe completely irrelevant, just a thought.
 


Quick Reply: Flaking piston



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:17 PM.