Springer Seat: Which springs are best?
#1
Springer Seat: Which springs are best?
So, I'm thinking of going with a springer seat. Any idea which springs are best....vertical or scissor? I know Harley has the scissor but I don't like the way they stick out the back and I feel the vertical has more of that throwback look.....but which works better?
#4
#6
The coil springs look better, but the hairpin springs work better.
I've tried different lengths of both before finally settling on 3.5" hairpin springs.
Coil springs are inherently,.....well, springier. They tend to bounce a few cycles more than you want them to. Coils that are fatter in the middle work better than the straight coils.
The hairpin springs are better at absorbing small bumps without bouncing as much, and they have more travel for absorbing big bumps.
I don't use my spring seat anymore because I changed the style of the bike. It's from Mother Road Customs. I have to say though, it's a very comfortable seat.
I've tried different lengths of both before finally settling on 3.5" hairpin springs.
Coil springs are inherently,.....well, springier. They tend to bounce a few cycles more than you want them to. Coils that are fatter in the middle work better than the straight coils.
The hairpin springs are better at absorbing small bumps without bouncing as much, and they have more travel for absorbing big bumps.
I don't use my spring seat anymore because I changed the style of the bike. It's from Mother Road Customs. I have to say though, it's a very comfortable seat.
#7
The coil springs look better, but the hairpin springs work better.
I've tried different lengths of both before finally settling on 3.5" hairpin springs.
Coil springs are inherently,.....well, springier. They tend to bounce a few cycles more than you want them to. Coils that are fatter in the middle work better than the straight coils.
The hairpin springs are better at absorbing small bumps without bouncing as much, and they have more travel for absorbing big bumps.
I don't use my spring seat anymore because I changed the style of the bike. It's from Mother Road Customs. I have to say though, it's a very comfortable seat.
I've tried different lengths of both before finally settling on 3.5" hairpin springs.
Coil springs are inherently,.....well, springier. They tend to bounce a few cycles more than you want them to. Coils that are fatter in the middle work better than the straight coils.
The hairpin springs are better at absorbing small bumps without bouncing as much, and they have more travel for absorbing big bumps.
I don't use my spring seat anymore because I changed the style of the bike. It's from Mother Road Customs. I have to say though, it's a very comfortable seat.
Trending Topics
#8
A few things to get you in the right direction.
Check out Mother Road Customs
There are many seat manufacturers, but this site shows a lot of variations.
Mine has the added 1" gel option on a 13" x 15" seat. It's easily as comfortable as other fixed seats. The springs make it even more so.
Look at:
Seat size - smaller seats, like the HD version, dig into my inner thighs and became extremely uncomfortable after a short while.
Seat material and added gel. - you don't want. To sit on a metal plate covered in leather. Gel makes a huge difference.
Spring length - read my other post on spring types. Longer hairpin springs worked best for me.
#9
A few things to get you in the right direction.
Check out Mother Road Customs
There are many seat manufacturers, but this site shows a lot of variations.
Mine has the added 1" gel option on a 13" x 15" seat. It's easily as comfortable as other fixed seats. The springs make it even more so.
Look at:
Seat size - smaller seats, like the HD version, dig into my inner thighs and became extremely uncomfortable after a short while.
Seat material and added gel. - you don't want. To sit on a metal plate covered in leather. Gel makes a huge difference.
Spring length - read my other post on spring types. Longer hairpin springs worked best for me.
Check out Mother Road Customs
There are many seat manufacturers, but this site shows a lot of variations.
Mine has the added 1" gel option on a 13" x 15" seat. It's easily as comfortable as other fixed seats. The springs make it even more so.
Look at:
Seat size - smaller seats, like the HD version, dig into my inner thighs and became extremely uncomfortable after a short while.
Seat material and added gel. - you don't want. To sit on a metal plate covered in leather. Gel makes a huge difference.
Spring length - read my other post on spring types. Longer hairpin springs worked best for me.
#10
I never tried reversing the springs. There's no reason it wouldn't work so long as there is enough space to avoid collapsing the travel on the coil. The stress is still acting between the mount points, so the coil location makes no difference.
I have 1" gel on mine, but I can't speak for your needs.