Anyone ever sat their rear end on both of these seats. Which would be better for a guy who is 5'8 185 lbs.? I'm looking to pick one up but not sure which one would fit the best.

 

I have both and both are not too bad. Every now and then I can feel the vintage wide in the back of my thighs. But with a screwed up back I need the back rest support the wide gives me.

 

I've had both. I'm 5' 9" 185 lbs as for comfort they are about the same. I had to go with the wide this year because that's the only way I could get one with a drivers backrest. Only thing I don't like about the wide is it's so wide it pushes my legs out at stops making it harder to flat foot. My bike felt like it had more more stability at stops with the standard wide.

 

Thanks guys!