Vote for keeping the fender on.

 

I like the fenderless look personally and alternate it with the weather. Fenderless does have its downfalls though. Riding out on one of our rarer sunny days I happened upon a dog turd that flew/splashed up across the headlamp glass, top tree. and handlebar clamp, before coming to rest on top of my crash helmet. All thought it amusing and its suppose to be lucky. NOT.

 

When a fender is used its from a V Rod as it suits the fatter 16" wheel and is a direct fit (Dynas and Rods share the same sliders)