2018+ Softail Models Breakout

Heritage Mod/Accessory Mini-Reviews

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
  #161  
Old 06-21-2020 | 07:22 AM
FranBunnyFFXII's Avatar
FranBunnyFFXII
Grand HDF Member
Veteran: National Guard
Joined: Oct 2018
Posts: 4,002
Likes: 2,978
From: Seattle
Default

Originally Posted by Hulkss

For perfect clutch action and performance I use Amsoil Synthetic Dirt Bike Transmission Fluid in the primary chain case.

The clutch is easy-peasy now.
Now that's an interesting development indeed.

I need to know what your thought process was that made you go for this, and how you came to using this fluid.
I was looking at using Amsoil's primary chaincase oil, what made you chose the dirtbike fluid over their dedicated chaincase oil?
 
The following users liked this post:
Bayou FLHR-M8-128" (11-13-2021)
  #162  
Old 06-21-2020 | 08:21 AM
Rampant Piper's Avatar
Rampant Piper
Novice
Veteran: Navy
Joined: Jun 2020
Posts: 17
Likes: 7
From: Lexington SC
Default

Originally Posted by void45
Wow - this is such a fantastic and useful thread!
I was thinking the same thing. I have ordered my 2020 Heritage Classic and it hasn't been built yet. I already have about 5 mods I plan on doing. I just don't know what to do first! This is gonna be a full time job for a while!
 
  #163  
Old 06-21-2020 | 12:13 PM
Hulkss's Avatar
Hulkss
Thread Starter
|
HDF Community Team
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 2,133
Likes: 1,956
From: Wisconsin
Community Team
Default

Originally Posted by FranBunnyFFXII
Now that's an interesting development indeed.
I need to know what your thought process was that made you go for this, and how you came to using this fluid.
I was looking at using Amsoil's primary chaincase oil, what made you chose the dirtbike fluid over their dedicated chaincase oil?
I am using a Rekluse Torque Drive clutch with 30% reduced spring pressure. This is possible due to the increased number of plates in the clutch. For maximum torque capacity when engaged and minimum viscous drag when the clutch is released, the oil viscosity should not be too high. Some primary oils are too thick in my opinion. They are sold in an attempt to reduce noise in the primary drive from the compensator and the chain/tensioner system.

I looked at several oils intended for the Harley Primary (not engine oils) and the cold/hot viscosity. The Dirt Bike transmission oil is very similar to other V-Twin primary oils that are at the lower end of available viscosities. Some others are much thicker which I avoided. The thinner oils are essentially 80W gear oils as far as viscosity is concerned. I really like the clutch action (no slip or grab) with the dirt bike oil and the primary is quiet and the clutch does not seem to wear at all.

Brand Cold/Hot viscosity
Redline 54.1/10.4 (V-Twin Primary)
Amsoil 147.1/18.7 (V-Twin Primary)
Amsoil 66.5/10.3 (Dirt Bike Transmission)
Schaeffer 94/11.5 (V-Twin Primary)

Many people report good results with Automatic Transmission Fluid (ATF) in the primary. It has a typical hot viscosity of 7.5 (maybe a little too low).

Harley tends to recommend a hot (100 C) viscosity of 20 which is based on using 20W50 oil in all three holes (engine, transmission, and primary). In my opinion the engine is fine at 20 (20W50 motor oil), the transmission should be around 27 (75W140 gear oil), and the primary should be around 10 (80W gear oil).
 

Last edited by Hulkss; 06-21-2020 at 01:04 PM.
  #164  
Old 06-21-2020 | 02:53 PM
FranBunnyFFXII's Avatar
FranBunnyFFXII
Grand HDF Member
Veteran: National Guard
Joined: Oct 2018
Posts: 4,002
Likes: 2,978
From: Seattle
Default

Originally Posted by Hulkss
For maximum torque capacity when engaged and minimum viscous drag when the clutch is released, the oil viscosity should not be too high. Some primary oils are too thick in my opinion. They are sold in an attempt to reduce noise in the primary drive from the compensator and the chain/tensioner system.
So lower viscosity in a primary fluid leads to better clutch engagement?
I didn't know that.

Does this account for only your Clutch? Or for essentially all clutch packs that can go in a harley primary?
What effect would this would have on say the SE 10plate clutch pack?
Thanks for the info.
 
  #165  
Old 06-21-2020 | 08:42 PM
Hulkss's Avatar
Hulkss
Thread Starter
|
HDF Community Team
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 2,133
Likes: 1,956
From: Wisconsin
Community Team
Default

Originally Posted by FranBunnyFFXII
So lower viscosity in a primary fluid leads to better clutch engagement?
I didn't know that.

Does this account for only your Clutch? Or for essentially all clutch packs that can go in a harley primary?
What effect would this would have on say the SE 10plate clutch pack?
Thanks for the info.
Wet clutch plates have to squeeze out the oil in order to grip. Oil that is too thick or with low friction modifiers can cause the clutch to slip. This is true for any wet clutch. Too thick or too much oil can cause the clutch drag when disengaged. That makes neutral hard to find.

Harley recently changed the clutch ramps to separate the plates more when disengaged. Probably due to drag and resulting trouble finding neutral with the clutch cable just a little out of adjustment (see attachment).
 
Attached Files
File Type: pdf
Clutch Ramp.pdf (156.1 KB, 198 views)
  #166  
Old 06-21-2020 | 08:46 PM
OldMike's Avatar
OldMike
Seasoned HDF Member
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 5,603
Likes: 1,939
From: Cleveland Zoo
Default

Originally Posted by Hulkss
I am using a Rekluse Torque Drive clutch with 30% reduced spring pressure. This is possible due to the increased number of plates in the clutch. For maximum torque capacity when engaged and minimum viscous drag when the clutch is released, the oil viscosity should not be too high. Some primary oils are too thick in my opinion. They are sold in an attempt to reduce noise in the primary drive from the compensator and the chain/tensioner system.

I looked at several oils intended for the Harley Primary (not engine oils) and the cold/hot viscosity. The Dirt Bike transmission oil is very similar to other V-Twin primary oils that are at the lower end of available viscosities. Some others are much thicker which I avoided. The thinner oils are essentially 80W gear oils as far as viscosity is concerned. I really like the clutch action (no slip or grab) with the dirt bike oil and the primary is quiet and the clutch does not seem to wear at all.

Brand Cold/Hot viscosity
Redline 54.1/10.4 (V-Twin Primary)
Amsoil 147.1/18.7 (V-Twin Primary)
Amsoil 66.5/10.3 (Dirt Bike Transmission)
Schaeffer 94/11.5 (V-Twin Primary)

Many people report good results with Automatic Transmission Fluid (ATF) in the primary. It has a typical hot viscosity of 7.5 (maybe a little too low).

Harley tends to recommend a hot (100 C) viscosity of 20 which is based on using 20W50 oil in all three holes (engine, transmission, and primary). In my opinion the engine is fine at 20 (20W50 motor oil), the transmission should be around 27 (75W140 gear oil), and the primary should be around 10 (80W gear oil).
Any idea how Harley Formula+ fits in?
 
  #167  
Old 06-21-2020 | 09:00 PM
Hulkss's Avatar
Hulkss
Thread Starter
|
HDF Community Team
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 2,133
Likes: 1,956
From: Wisconsin
Community Team
Default

Originally Posted by OldMike
Any idea how Harley Formula+ fits in?
According to documentation I've seen online, Harley Formula+ is a 50W on the motor oil scale, so the viscosity would be about 20 cSt at 100 C.
 
The following users liked this post:
OldMike (06-21-2020)
  #168  
Old 06-21-2020 | 09:02 PM
FranBunnyFFXII's Avatar
FranBunnyFFXII
Grand HDF Member
Veteran: National Guard
Joined: Oct 2018
Posts: 4,002
Likes: 2,978
From: Seattle
Default

Interesting info, thanks.
 
  #169  
Old 07-08-2020 | 11:57 AM
Hulkss's Avatar
Hulkss
Thread Starter
|
HDF Community Team
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 2,133
Likes: 1,956
From: Wisconsin
Community Team
Default

After I moved the floorboards out 3/4" with Kuryakyn spacers, it felt a little awkward getting my foot on the brake pedal. I added this extended brake pedal pad. It works great with the SoftBrake lever I am using (see earlier post).


 
  #170  
Old 07-08-2020 | 01:07 PM
tmac00333's Avatar
tmac00333
Grand HDF Member
Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 4,710
Likes: 1,917
From: Florida
Default

Originally Posted by Hulkss
After I moved the floorboards out 3/4" with Kuryakyn spacers, it felt a little awkward getting my foot on the brake pedal. I added this extended brake pedal pad. It works great with the SoftBrake lever I am using (see earlier post).
This will be my next mod. I always feel like my feet are slipping off these skinny boards. I'm not sure 3/4" will be enough for me, though. I'm splay-footed, like a five-dollar mule.

 



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:58 PM.