Power Commander or SE Race Tuner
Thread Starter
|
Tourer
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 277
Likes: 0
From: I'm nation wide
Power Commander or SE Race Tuner
A while back, I had minor head work done, installed a power commander, Bassani Headers with Rhinhart mufflers, 10:5:1 pistons and SE 258 cams.
As a result of not getting the tq and HP I wanted, I had more work done to the heads, switched to Thunderheaders, installed 10:5:1 CP pistons. and went to Woods T5-6 cams. I kept the Power commander. The stats went up to 97 Hp and 112 tq.
My question is:
If I remove the Power Commander and install a SE race Tuner, I'll add a big sucker as well, what are the odds of improving my numbers by using the Race Tuner? can some one give me an idea about what the numbers may turn out to be?
Also what cam should I use to step up the HP and TQ if the Race Tuner is installed? (What are the anticipated numbers with a different cam?)
I'm under the impression Race Tuners are better than Power Commanders ?????
As a result of not getting the tq and HP I wanted, I had more work done to the heads, switched to Thunderheaders, installed 10:5:1 CP pistons. and went to Woods T5-6 cams. I kept the Power commander. The stats went up to 97 Hp and 112 tq.
My question is:
If I remove the Power Commander and install a SE race Tuner, I'll add a big sucker as well, what are the odds of improving my numbers by using the Race Tuner? can some one give me an idea about what the numbers may turn out to be?
Also what cam should I use to step up the HP and TQ if the Race Tuner is installed? (What are the anticipated numbers with a different cam?)
I'm under the impression Race Tuners are better than Power Commanders ?????
I don't think one is better over another. People have had good results with PC3/V, SERT, TTS, ThunderMax, etc.
What are your end goals? How much power do you want and how much money do you have? Who is your tuner and does the tuner have a good rep for getting power?
...gene
What are your end goals? How much power do you want and how much money do you have? Who is your tuner and does the tuner have a good rep for getting power?
...gene
Road Warrior
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 1,984
Likes: 7
You can remove a PC, it is a add on.
You cannot remove a SERT, it is a device to connect to the ECM. Connect it, download the new program you want, then you unhook it. Everything stays all stock. The program inside the ECM is changed to what you want.
I like and use the TTS Mastertune. Kind of a better SERT. In fact I think these guys will upgrade your SERT for a little.
You cannot remove a SERT, it is a device to connect to the ECM. Connect it, download the new program you want, then you unhook it. Everything stays all stock. The program inside the ECM is changed to what you want.
I like and use the TTS Mastertune. Kind of a better SERT. In fact I think these guys will upgrade your SERT for a little.
Road Warrior
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 1,360
Likes: 4
You may want to check these out:
https://www.hdforums.com.au/Default....238&view=topic
http://www.hotbikeweb.com/tech/0911_...une/index.html
https://www.hdforums.com.au/Default....238&view=topic
http://www.hotbikeweb.com/tech/0911_...une/index.html
Last edited by ColdCase; Oct 22, 2009 at 09:24 PM.
Ultimate HDF Member
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 5,926
Likes: 138
From: NE Ohio
A while back, I had minor head work done, installed a power commander, Bassani Headers with Rhinhart mufflers, 10:5:1 pistons and SE 258 cams.
As a result of not getting the tq and HP I wanted, I had more work done to the heads, switched to Thunderheaders, installed 10:5:1 CP pistons. and went to Woods T5-6 cams. I kept the Power commander. The stats went up to 97 Hp and 112 tq.
My question is:
If I remove the Power Commander and install a SE race Tuner, I'll add a big sucker as well, what are the odds of improving my numbers by using the Race Tuner? can some one give me an idea about what the numbers may turn out to be?
Also what cam should I use to step up the HP and TQ if the Race Tuner is installed? (What are the anticipated numbers with a different cam?)
I'm under the impression Race Tuners are better than Power Commanders ?????
As a result of not getting the tq and HP I wanted, I had more work done to the heads, switched to Thunderheaders, installed 10:5:1 CP pistons. and went to Woods T5-6 cams. I kept the Power commander. The stats went up to 97 Hp and 112 tq.
My question is:
If I remove the Power Commander and install a SE race Tuner, I'll add a big sucker as well, what are the odds of improving my numbers by using the Race Tuner? can some one give me an idea about what the numbers may turn out to be?
Also what cam should I use to step up the HP and TQ if the Race Tuner is installed? (What are the anticipated numbers with a different cam?)
I'm under the impression Race Tuners are better than Power Commanders ?????
Advanced
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 80
Likes: 0
The POWER COMMANDER mainly does 2 things - allows air fuel ratio changes and also advance adjustments. The other products, that allow internal software changes of the ecm, can do many more adjustments than the PC. Let's say you want a 13.0 afr at 100% throttle from 2000rpms to 6000rpms, and both the SERT and PC do that for you, than that portion of the tuning process would be the same. As for advance, the PC will probably serve your purpose, unless you have a really radical engine. That being said, if you have somebody around that really knows how to work the SERT (and others) you won't go wrong with the SERT(AND OTHERS). If you don't have a SERT tuner around, face it, you spend 99.9% of your time going less than 100% throttle. Even if (and I'm not saying this would happen) at 100% throttle you got 1HP or 1LB of torque less with the PC, I really don't think you would miss it. This is just my 2cent opinion.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
